Sunday, September 2, 2012

Country Music Triple Header – End of Summer Singles 2002 vs. 2007 vs. 2012



While listening to the radio the other day, I started to get curious as to how today’s single would match up to the singles of a few years back.  As a result, I decided to put together a head to head to head battle of the singles on the August 31st/September 1st Billboard Country Songs charts of 2002, 2007, and 2012.

1)   Kenny Chesney - The Good Stuff (2002) vs. Kenny Chesney - Never Wanted Nothing More (2007)  vs. Blake Shelton – Over (2012)

Winner:  Kenny Chesney - Never Wanted Nothing More (2007)

Kenny is THE master of summer songs.  Never Wanted Nothing More, while not island themed like many of Chesney’s repertoire, captures the light-hearted feel of summertime.  Next time you are on the beach or at a BBQ having fun in the warm sunshine with your favorite people, listen to this song and tell me you’re not compelled to sing these lyrics with conviction:
"I'm sure happy with what I've got.
I live to love and laugh a lot, and that's all I need."

2)   Dixie Chicks - Long Time Gone (2002) vs. Rodney Atkins - These Are My People (2007) vs. Love And Theft – Angel Eyes (2012)

Winner: Rodney Atkins – These Are My People (2007)

I am pretty addicted to Angel Eyes right now, but These Are My People wins for its mass appeal and relatability to a country music audience.  Life in a small town is a common theme in country, but not every song is this catchy, this fun, and hit number 1.

3)   Tim McGraw - Unbroken (2002) vs. Reba McEntire and Kelly Clarkson - Because Of You (2007)  vs. Little Big Town – Pontoon (2012)

Winner: Reba and Kelly Clarkson - Because Of You (2007)

The pop version featuring only Kelly Clarkson is powerful, but Reba and Kelly’s duet is gut-wrenching.  The song has the ability to put a knot in your throat by making you feel the pain of the storytellers, the mark of an impeccable song.

4)   Darryl Worley - I Miss My Friend (2002) vs. Rascal Flatts – Take Me There (2007) vs. Josh Turner – Time Is Love (2012)

Winner: Rascal Flatts – Take Me There (2007)

Driving beat with spot-on instrumentation?  Soaring vocals?  Lyrics that encapsulate the curiosity and exploration of new love?  Check, check, and check!  Take Me There is one of Rascal Flatt’s best songs, and it happens to have Kenny Chesney as one of its writers.  It is a perfect song for a playlist of any romantic just starting to fall head over heels.

5)   Tracy Byrd - Ten Rounds With Jose Cuervo (2002) vs. Brooks & Dunn – Proud Of The House We Built (2007) vs. Gloriana - (Kissed You) Good Night (2012)

Winner:  Tracy Byrd - Ten Rounds With Jose Cuervo (2002)

This is one of the best post-break up drinking songs ever.  It’s too fun to resist. 

6)   Sara Evans - I Keep Looking (2002) vs. Bucky Covington - A Different World (2007) vs. Kenny Chesney – Come Over (2012)

Winner: Sara Evans - I Keep Looking (2002)

I Keep Looking is an upbeat look at the often frustrating human condition.  It takes the prize because there is not a soul on earth, or at least in America, that can deny feeling the exact same way as the storyteller:
"they say it's only human to never be satisfied...just as soon as I get what I want, I get unsatisfied...good is good but could be better...I keep looking, looking for something more..."

7)   Toby Keith - Courtesy Of The Red White And Blue (2002) vs. Toby Keith - Love Me If You Can (2007) vs. The Band Perry - Postcard From Paris (2012)

Winner: Toby Keith - Courtesy Of The Red, White And Blue (2002)

Patriotic with a “you can’t #*@& with us!” attitude, Courtesy Of The Red, White And Blue is probably Toby’s most notorious song.  (I highly recommend seeing him perform it live.)  It is the pro-America, angry, screw-the-terrorists side of the post-9/11 United States, back when there was still some of the united-we-stand feeling left to be had in this country. 

8)   Joe Nichols - The Impossible (2002) vs. Keith Urban - I Told You So (2007) vs. Hunter Hayes – Wanted (2012)

Winner: Hunter Hayes – Wanted (2012)

Guys take notice – EVERY girl wants to feel wanted.  Whether you have been together for 40 days or 40 years, never let her stop feeling wanted.  Hunter may only be 20, but he has already written about a very important lesson to be learned.  It is a great love song.

9)   Diamond Rio - Beautiful Mess (2002) vs. Sugarland – Everyday America (2007) vs. Jana Kramer – Why Ya Wanna (2012)

Winner: Diamond Rio – Beautiful Mess (2002)

The verses have an almost sexy vibe, while the chorus is your standard, mass appeal catchy hook.  The duality is what makes this song a cut above the rest.  Plus, I’d rather be a beautiful mess in love than a hot mess looking for love!

10) Andy Griggs - Tonight I Wanna Be Your Man (2002) vs. Tim McGraw and Faith Hill - I Need You  (2007) vs. Keith Urban – For You (2012)

Winner: Tim McGraw and Faith Hill – I Need You (2007)

I Need You is one of the best country love songs of the past decade.  Established by its minimal instrumental accompaniment, pure emotional delivery by its performers, and lyrics that capture the aching need to be with the one you love despite your own vices and selfish desires, the raw feel of this single is what makes it so impactful.

Had the match ups been between other weeks on the charts, the results could have been very different, but this battle goes to 2007’s batch of singles.

Final Scorecard:
2007 – 5 wins
2002 – 4 wins
2012 – 1 win

No comments:

Post a Comment